FAULTY BOOK REVIEW

FaultCoverI finished reading THE FAULT IN OUR STARS, by John Green.  This is a best-seller about two terminally ill teenagers who are in love.  Green has attempted to capture the true essence of two youngsters whose lives are eroding.  He confesses that it has taken him some years and several tries to get it right, meaning not presenting the oft-exaggerated and maligned images healthy adults usually conjure up about dying kids.  It is a good story and the book deserves the attention it is getting.  It is, however, the kind of literature that leaves me feeling downright stupid.  I hate when this happens.

THE FAULT IN OUR STARS was a difficult book for me to enjoy.  You may find “enjoy” an inappropriate word to describe a story about two dying kids, but this particular book was written to be enjoyed…enjoyed for its humor and sensitivity, along with its expression of true love.  There was, perhaps, a lot more meaningful reward to be extracted from reading the book, but not by me.  My intellectual capacity took a hit.

 Often, when faced with serious, intellectually stimulating material, one is inclined to display a “hmm, yes, I see!” response rather than appear stymied.  I used to be like that.  I didn’t like to admit I was dumb.  I remember my reaction after seeing the movie, 2001: A Space Odyssey.  Of course I understood the meaning of the obelisk, didn’t you?  Truth be told, I had no idea what the hell it meant.  It was this big rock that shot up out of the ground while synced up with what became an iconic piece of music.  I told people I got it…but my real self was muttering WTF!   I don’t disguise myself anymore.  I am at the age where I don’t care if folks think I’m stupid because I don’t understand Shakespeare (and I never have) or a piece of art makes no sense to me…or a book spews off enough esoteric rhetoric that it soars at lightning speed way off the top of my head.  Today I simply admit I don’t get it.

There is a lot in THE FAULT IN OUR STARS that I don’t get.  There is too much symbolism and too much “deep thoughts” that whiz by me leaving a numbing disconnect.  Many times I had to stop, go back and re-read a paragraph because I could not understand what was being said.  After reading it a second time, I still did not understand what was being said.  It is annoying as hell because the story is good and the characters are wonderful…but I don’t understand half of what they are saying.  No doubt it will become a much discussed “reading group” kind of book and teachers will have their students writing essays about it.

Crap, I wish I were smarter.  Crap, I hate wishing I wish I were smarter…makes me feel inadequate.  And, sadly, that is what this book has done.  So, I am reduced to deciding what to decide about this book—is it the fault of the book that I have missed so much of what it has to offer?  …or is it the fault in my stars?

 *****

Need I remind you that it is still May and May is International Green Month (see May 5th Blog)

Note the name of the author of THE FAULT IN OUR STARS …Love it when a plan comes together!

*****

Books by Marc Kuhn: THE POPE’S STONE, an historical novel that follows two descendants of a Virginia family who, despite living a century apart, share uncanny similarities in their lives; NEVER GOOSE A MOOSE, a collection of whimsical verse featuring thought-provoking “never-do’s” that children should beware of; and ABOUT A FARM, a children’s book about challenges we all face every day, regardless of where we live.  All three books are available at amazon.com and each has its own .com website under its title.

Intimate details about Marc Kuhn and other exhilarating stuff at marckuhn.com

Marc’s Blog is copyrighted 2012, 2013, Marc L. Kuhn.  Reblogging is permitted with notification to author and if presented with attribution to source.  Other reproduction, whether in whole or in part, must receive permission from author.  Contact author via comment on this blog space or at info@marckuhn.com.

Illustrations used within this blog are culled from available images on the Internet.  Copyrighted material is not intentionally displayed.  If a source is provided, attribution is included on the blog.  There is no attempt to steal or devalue any material used within this blog.  If you have an issue or concern about anything included in the text or illustrations on this blog, please contact the author

4 Responses to FAULTY BOOK REVIEW

  1. Chibivy says:

    Some says that Mr. Green’s writing style is somewhat pretentious, and I could probably agree. But I like the way it is pretentious and metaphorical and filled with symbolism, because it’s like a “secret language” between the author and his readers. Like, you cannot really ‘understand’ the quotes right away unless to truly read the book. It felt like we fans have some sort of “ownership” and “belongingness” with the book, which kept us apart from those who use the wonderful phrases of the book without actually reading its entirety. :)

    I hope you enjoyed TFiOS, nevertheless. ;)

    • Marc Kuhn says:

      Dear Chibivy …you are probably right and that is why I did not enjoy the book as much as I wanted–I don’t like secrets and I don’t like mind games. Perhaps it is because I worked in communications (radio) all my life and needed to be clear and precise in getting my thoughts across to the audience. TFIOS is not for pragmatic people like me. However, Green’s art was not wasted on me. I had no problem getting through the book…it just ran into some problems getting through to me! I love your passion, Chibivy–don’t lose it because that is what is important.

  2. Chibivy says:

    The Fault in Our Stars is one of my favorite novels! It is beautiful yet heartbreaking at the same time.

    Mr. John Green actually writes for young adults, and TFiOS is a YA novel. Probably, Sir Marc, this novel is filled with jargons of this generation which made you quite confused by some parts.

    It’s still nice to hear that a person like you read YA novels. It’s good to explore different genre, yes? And it could also make you understand today’s generation, especially that you write people. :)

    • Marc Kuhn says:

      Dear Chibivy….I’m not so sure it’s a generation gap. I have kids around me all the time and I am “up” on most things. That is why I have no problem reading a YA book. There’s just a little too much what I call “intellectualism” going on in this book. Mine is a very simple mind. I don’t like philosophers; I like my thinking in easily understood language that I don’t have to ponder about. Nevertheless, you may be right…and you have full right to list this book as one of your favorites.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 528 other followers

%d bloggers like this: